This years’ dose of market volatility brought to you by... COVID-19
Anytime we hear the old refrain “this time it’s different” or “don’t worry, this is just the same as before” regarding the market ‐ alarm bells begin to go off in our heads. While market volatility and corrections of 10% seem to have become more the norm lately that does not mean we should ignore them and just go merrily on our way. Neither should we panic blindly due to the media touting “largest point fall ever”, which it was, but as a percentage not so.
We have not seen a significant correction since the end of 2018 so, in a way you could say one was overdue and could just as easily been set off by this as something else. The cause of this volatility however is slightly different, and we are paying special attention to it. It could go away relatively quickly, and markets would likely rebound quickly... but it could also be prolonged and tip the world into a global recession which we would still recover from but might take much longer.
In general, many of our partners have been finding the market pricey as of late and difficult to find great new investments. They have been raising the amount of cash they have on hand over the last year to 18 months in order to look for company/stocks going on sale in market dips. It appears that although they were waiting for an opportunity like this, they are going to continue to be patient and careful before starting to buy in in this case. It makes us feel good that they are being extra careful. We would rather miss a little bit of the “sale” than rush blindly in without good data.
It is important to understand that the managers are constantly fine tuning the portfolios to reduce risk in areas of concern or increase/decrease cash holdings or take advantage of a market dip to get a good deal on a particular stock. This is not to be confused with taking large portfolio bets, this is done with a great deal of thought and research. They try to use short term volatility to actually increase their performance compared to the markets.
We are constantly receiving research from our partners. They take special care to make sure that when there is market turmoil, we get even more up to date research and thoughts from the managers and economists who help us manage your investments. As usual we are sifting through all kinds of research to make sure we are able to help you make the most informed decisions possible regarding your investments. We thought providing you some quotes from our partners might be interesting to some of you. The following are clipped from the hundreds of pages we have been through in the past week.
Eric Benner, Global and US equities Dynamic “it is important for us to remember that corrections are a normal (even healthy) part of functioning markets and occur in more years than not. There were two such corrections in 2018 (the latter quite deep), which provided an attractive setup for 2019” “over time if events turn out more benignly, we’re getting our shopping list ready” February 2020
David Fingold, Vice president & Senior Portfolio Manager for Dynamic “As is our custom we mitigate risk by raising cash. We have done this throughout our tenure. Similar to prior corrections we are looking for the signals that will lead us to put that cash to work.” February 27, 2020
Bill McCleod, Canadian equities for Dynamic “This is not a SARS‐like event and the SARS playbook is not applicable. The risk of “a recession driven by inventory correction and travel industry (with some associated financial distress) remains the primary downside scenario.”
“we remain on the sidelines generally, with high cash levels. We are waiting for either better entry points or better data.” February 2020
Oscar Belaiche, Head of equity income team for Dynamic “As always corrections don’t hit you between the eyes, they whack you in the back of the head.”
“Dynamic Strategic yield fund and Dynamic Dividend income fund have raised cash to over 10%.”
“our view in this environment would be to have a shopping list prepared ready to begin buying once we believe the Coronavirus situation is settling down, i.e. the 2nd derivative of change is “less bad”. Currently the situation is “more bad”” February 2020
Todd Martina, PHD Senior VP, Chief economist Mackenzie Investments ‐ “investors were initially reassured by China’s robust measures to contain the rapid outbreak.”
“However, the coronavirus narrative began to shift in late February as the contagion accelerated internationally.”
“Forecasting the short‐term economic impact of the outbreak is inherently uncertain given the unprecedented nature of the virus.” “As the spread of the contagion stabilizes, we expect a bounce in economic activity as global supply chains resume normal functioning.” February 27, 2020
Tye Bousada President and Chief Investment Officer Edgepoint wrote recently regarding market volatility reminding us that an investor who invested $100 in Berkshire Hathaway 55 years ago would now have approximately $2.7 million but........ there were 3 times that your investment would have been down more that 50%, there were 18 years when the stock performed worse than the S&P (11 of those years by more than 10%).
Further he comments on the “Absolute Dread” of watching investments go down in value and I quote “You’ve surely seen a video of a herd of gazelles being chased by a lion. They’re running for their lives. Most people feel that way in the stock market at some point during their investment journey. Prices are going down, panic sets in and there’s a stampede to sell. The stampede occurs because there’s very few things in life as uncomfortable as watching the price of something you own go down if you don’t know what the value of it is. Most people don’t know the true value of what they own, so dread sets in. The easiest thing to do is sell, so they join the stampede.
Here’s the positive side to the absolute dread – unlike the average participant in the stock market, we make it our job to know the value of the businesses we own and to take advantage of that dread. We certainly haven’t been perfect, but nothing in the past has helped us buy more growth for free than a good stampede. Here are some of the previous stampedes that you or someone you know may have found themselves in:
The economic slowdown in the fourth quarter of 2018
The U.S. debt downgrade of 2011
The European sovereign debt crisis of 2011/12
The U.S. financial crisis of 2008/2009
9/11
The dot‐com bubble burst of 2000 to 2002
The emerging market crisis of the mid‐1990s.”
According to the CDC, in 2017/2018, in the United States alone 45 million Americans contracted the flu leading to 810,000 hospitalizations and 61,000 Flu related deaths. We only remark on the CDC statistic to remind us of perspective when considering current market upheavals.